The goldhagen thesis and historical truth

See the essay on which one part of this book is based and the essay on which the other part is based. Purporting to solve the mystery of the Nazi holocaust, Goldhagen maintains that ordinary Germans were driven by fanatical anti-Semitism to murder the Jews.

The goldhagen thesis and historical truth

Friday, October 24, Finkelstein. A Nation on trial. The Goldhagen thesis and historical truth. Goldhagen has threatened the Ruth Birn with a suit. The posting of these two articles in no way implies that their authors share any other views expressed on this Website. The E-mail of the Secretariat is: We see the act of displaying a written document on Internet as the equivalent to displaying it on the shelves of a public library.

It costs us a modicum of labor and money.

The goldhagen thesis and historical truth

The only benefit accrues to the reader who, we surmise, thinks by himself. A reader looks for a document on the Web at his or her own risks. As for the author, there is no reason to suppose that he or she shares any responsibility for other writings displayed on this Site.

Because laws enforcing a specific censorship on some historical question apply in various countries Germany, France, Israel, Switzerland, Canada, and others we do not ask their permission from authors living in thoses places: We believe we are protected by article 19 of the Human Rights Charter: Finkelstein In the opinion, not of bad men, but of the best men, no belief which is contrary to truth can be really useful Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust 1.

Every important journal of opinion printed one or more reviews within weeks of its release. Although initial reviews were not uniformly positive, once the Goldhagen juggernaut proved unstoppable, even the dissenting voices joined in the chorus of praise.

The bulk of what follows documents this claim. In the conclusion I speculate on the broader meaning of the Goldhagen phenomenon. Before the Genocide Genocide was immanent in the conversation of German society.

It was immanent in its language and emotion. It was immanent in the structure of cognition. A Nation Crazy with Hatred? No moral problem proved insurmountable. When all participating personnel were put to the test, there were very few lingerers and almost no deserters. It is not intrinsically racist or otherwise illegitimate.

There is no obvious reason why a culture cannot be fanatically consumed by hatred. He argues that, for centuries, nearly every German was possessed of a homicidal animus toward Jews. Thus, he suggests that more than per cent of the German people would have relished the occasion to torture and murder Jews.

Consider that he repeatedly contradicts it. Yet the question still remains, whence the hatred of Jews? A nation of genocidal racists is, after all, not exactly a commonplace.

On this crucial issue, Goldhagen sheds no light.

A nation on trial : the Goldhagen thesis and historical truth

Anti-Semitism, he suggests, was symptomatic of a much deeper German malaise. Goldhagen depicts anti-Semitism as the manifestation of a deranged state.

Moby Dick had earlier mangled him. To quote Melville from the passage Goldhagen excerpts: Indeed, he emphatically denies that Jews bear any responsibility for anti-Semitism: Unlike the Sonderweg proponents, he never once anchors the deformations of the German character in temporal developments.

Germans bear no individual or, for that matter, collective guilt. It shared none of our basic values.Fortunately, many of those who are not blinded by political correctness can see through the absurdity of this farce presented as historical thesis.

In this book, two essays are presented which attempt to refute Goldhagen's thesis. The first is by Norman Finkelstein, himself a .

Biography. Daniel Goldhagen was born in Boston, Massachusetts, to Erich and Norma grew up in nearby Newton. His wife Sarah (née Williams) is an architectural historian, and critic for The New Republic magazine..

Daniel Goldhagen's father is Erich Goldhagen, a retired Harvard professor. Daniel Jonah Goldhagen's "crazy" thesis: a critique of Hitler's willing executioners / Norman G. Finkelstein --Revising the holocaust / Ruth Bettina Birn.

Responsibility: Norman G. Finkelstein and Ruth Bettina Birn. Editor’s Note: Excerpted, in shortened form, from Dr.

The goldhagen thesis and historical truth

Brown’s recent book 60 Questions Christians Ask About Jewish Beliefs and Practices. Why have Jewish people been so hated . Find great deals for A Nation on Trial: The Goldhagen Thesis and Historical Truth by Norman G. Finkelstein and Ruth Bettina Birn (, Paperback, Revised).

Shop with confidence on eBay! Goldhagen's thesis, however, neither renders the Nazi holocaust intelligible nor is it historical. For argument's sake, let us assume that Goldhagen is correct. Consumed by a ferocious loathing of the Jews, the German people jumped at Hitler's invitation to exterminate them.

A Nation on Trial: The Goldhagen Thesis and Historical Truth by Norman G. Finkelstein